Reviewer Guidelines

Peer reviewers are essential to the quality of FJIAS. The journal operates a double-blind peer-review process: reviewers and authors do not know each other's identities.

Before accepting an invitation

  • Accept only if the manuscript is within your expertise and you can complete the review on time.
  • Decline if you have any conflict of interest (for example, recent collaboration, same institution or department, or a personal or financial interest).
  • Please respond to the invitation within 7 days and submit your review within 21 days of accepting.

Confidentiality

  • Treat the manuscript as confidential. Do not share it or use its content before publication.
  • Do not upload the manuscript or your report to AI tools (see the AI Policy).

What to assess

  • Originality and relevance to the journal's Aims & Scope.
  • Soundness of the experimental design, methodology and statistical analysis.
  • Whether the results support the conclusions, and whether the discussion is placed in the context of recent literature.
  • Clarity of presentation, quality of figures and tables, and adequacy of references.
  • Any concerns about plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication or ethics.

Writing the report

  • Start with a short summary of the manuscript and its main contribution.
  • List major and minor comments separately, with specific, constructive suggestions.
  • Be objective and courteous; avoid personal remarks.
  • Use the confidential comments box for remarks intended only for the editor.

Recommendation

Choose one of: Accept, Minor Revisions, Major Revisions, Resubmit for Review, Resubmit Elsewhere, or Decline. The final decision rests with the editor.

Recognition

Reviewers receive a Certificate of Appreciation for each completed review.

To join the reviewer database, please register and select the Reviewer role, listing your areas of expertise as keywords.